Content deleted Content added
Line 512: * I support {{U|EdChem}} request to clarify the T in TBAN. Topics: (1) WP:ELEM: {{tl|WikiProject Elements}} ({{cl|WikiProject Elements articles}}; includes WP:ISOTOPES b/c is merged into WP:ELEMENTS); (2) [[WP:TBAN]] is clear, e.g. lists ''parts'' of other pages (all ns's) about the Topic. For example "TBAN Weather" includes "{{slink|California|Climate}}". (3) Not included is [[WP:IBAN]], which is a different approach. So far, clear enough I think. About WP:CHEM or WP:PHARM articles, like for example [[guanine]] or {{tl|Therapeutic radiopharmaceuticals}}: IMO the "parts" criterium in WP:TBAN cover these. Any more bordercases to look at? -[[User:DePiep|DePiep]] ([[User talk:DePiep|talk]]) 12:09, 2 January 2021 (UTC) *'''Question'''. I added {{slink||About article Periodic table}} to my original reply. It illustrates that the article was treated rough, under the (now disapproved) editing & discussion processes. Since it has an FA star, would it be reasonable to ''revert to status ex-ante'' (pre-mistreatment i.e., as of pre Nov 15, 2020) [https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Periodic_table&oldid=987955309]? I'm sure improvements can be added or re-added, based on sound discussion, esp since EdChem provided good first criticism (unused so far). As a detail, we could consider keeping the category changes, provided the Rationale, sourcing and copyediting is acceptable. -[[User:DePiep|DePiep]] ([[User talk:DePiep|talk]]) 18:07, 2 January 2021 (UTC) *'''Supplementary note:''' I had intended to cease commenting, however my case, and related matters are still being discussed. ::* EdChem [[User_talk:DePiep#Apology|posted an apology to DePiep]] regarding "triggering posts" and "emotional triggers," and the pain and anguish associated with such. ::*I'm a very recent survivor of long-term medically diagnosed [[Major_depressive_disorder|clinical depression]]. This included bouts of considering how to kill myself. The [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Van_Gogh_-_Trauernder_alter_Mann.jpeg picture by van Gogh] says it all. I'm OK now, having obtained help from professionals. I'm still on medication. Among other things, editing WP gives me purpose and meaning. I suspect I'm resilient enough not to lapse into depression during my topic ban. That is why I proposed a voluntary ban, to maintain at least some connection with WP:ELEM collegues, and the meaning and purpose of WP:ELEM goals. I was not going to mention this. However I saw {{u|EdChem}}'s post to {{u|DePiep}}, so there it is. ::*I will not be posting to WP:ELEM, part from interesting publication alerts, and consensus requests (which I will not be discussing further), unless I am pinged, questioned, or invited. ::*Re the '''question from [[User talk:Games of the world|Games of the world]],''' I'll answer shortly. --- [[User:Sandbh|Sandbh]] ([[User talk:Sandbh|talk]]) 00:56, 3 January 2021 (UTC) ====Proposal: Self-imposed editing restrictions and conditions==== | |||