Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/JOM Charity Award: Difference between revisions - Wikipedia

Tags: Mobile edit Mobile web edit Advanced mobile edit

Line 24:

*'''Delete''' per the nomination analysis. It fails [[WP:GNG]]. This appears to be a case of undisclosed paid editing. The sources cited in this article are advertorial/PR material pretending to be independent secondary sources. Though this sources are from reliable independent media news organisations, the press articles are PR efforts. The creator of this page is likely to be working for a PR Firm. They currently have two of their articles in [[WP:AFD]] and the two of them use same media sources, the writing are similar and the authors are mostly same. It is not a coincidence that should be overlooked. Their promotional articles in AFD are [[Gbenga Adigun]] and [[JOM Charity Award]]. See these two different sources and their bylines from The Sun (Nigeria) cited in both pages [https://sunnewsonline.com/top-five-prestigious-awards/] and [https://sunnewsonline.com/television-feature-gbenga-adigun-for-real-estate-development-contribution/] written by same person (John Mike). See these two sources in both pages from Daily Times (Nigeria) and take note of their bylines even though they are covering different beats [https://dailytimesng.com/awards-that-garnered-international-prestige-and-fame/] and [https://dailytimesng.com/jom-charity-awards-making-peoples-work-feel-valued/] written by same person ( Ihesiulo Grace). Now see these two different sources from Leadership cited in both pages [https://leadership.ng/empowerment-real-estate-entrepreneurship-key-to-economic-growth-adigun/] and [https://leadership.ng/awards-as-tokens-of-honour-that-society-bestows/] written by same person (Christopher Odey). Also see these two different sources from the PM News cited in both pages [https://pmnewsnigeria.com/2020/07/23/british-nigerian-writer-nominated-for-jom-charity-awards/] and [https://pmnewsnigeria.com/2021/01/28/gbenga-adigun-transforming-nigerian-landscape-and-housing-market/] written by same person (Taiwo Okanlawon). It is safe to say that this editor and those commenting Keep are working for same PR firm. Closing admin, please, take note of these editors commenting keep, they are most likely to be working together. [[User:Piscili|Piscili]] ([[User talk:Piscili|talk]]) 13:39, 19 May 2024 (UTC)

*'''Comment''':My account was created 9 months ago and some of these publications were existing long before I join Wikipedia. Check my contribution on Wikipedia has been from a neutral perspective. I feel you and the nominator might be using this account to discredit the article because I could see the desperation to discredit it. Because he went ahead to report to the admin. And also nominated this article and the award so he won't be able to scale through with [[WP:ANYBIO]]

Piscili , face the issues instead of trying to discredit a credible publishing house.

The articles has potential of passing [[WP:BASIC]], [[WP:GNG]], [[WP:ANYBIO]] and certainly with [[WP:NACADEMIC]] as a fellow of a highly prestigious institute of learning.[[User:Calyx2s|Calyx2s]] ([[User talk:Calyx2s|talk]]) 18:14, 19 May 2024 (UTC)