Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tracy Davidson: Difference between revisions - Wikipedia

Line 20:

*'''Delete''' Asa Aarons wannabe in a small city big deal. [[User:ConeyCyclone|ConeyCyclone]] 17:24, 12 Jun 2005 (UTC)

*'''Keep''' This is from the same user who writes about many New York City-based tv news personalities and executives, but derides those from "lesser" stations in major markets. And by looking at the nominator's reasoning, I suppose everyone knows who [[Diane Doctor]] is. [[User:ErikNY|ErikNY]] 18:58, 12 Jun 2005 (UTC)

**'''COMMENT''' What the above user calls "New York City-based tv news personalities and executives" are nationally known people who meet many of the [[WP:BIO]] criteria or are seen nationally on programs. If we use ErikNY's reasoning we should just ignore people like [[Peter Jennings]] and [[Roone Arledge]] would fall into that category. The broadcasts of the various New York televison stations are seen through much of the United States, the Carribean and Latin America, unlike Ms. Davidson, who is only seen in a very small area by comparison. Also, in the case of say [[Jim Vance]] or [[Sue Simmons]] who are pioneering African-American news anchors, so they would warrant entries, but Ms. Davidson a thirty something blonde cookie cutter anchorette. She doesn't need one until she becomes more notable or moves on to a national broadcast. [[User:Spotteddogsdotorg|Spotteddogsdotorg]] 23:04, 12 Jun 2005 (UTC)

*'''Delete''' doesn't meet [[WP:BIO]] guidelines. You may argue that she is a "Well known entertainment figure", but being known in one city doesn't seem to do that. [[User:Toasthaven|Toasthaven]] 22:47, 12 Jun 2005 (UTC)